Comparison

Formclock vs When I Work

When I Work set the bar for shift trading. Formclock exceeds it with an auditable marketplace and an agent that ranks the swaps.

Start free See pricing
Formclock vs When I Work: feature by feature
FeatureFormclockWhen I Work
Shift trading & pickupsAuditable, agent-ranked, reversibleYes
Autonomous coverageAgent acts at your chosen autonomyManual
Compliance before publishEnforced, versioned rule packsBasic
Labour cost vs budgetBuilt in per locationAdd-on
One app, no add-onsEverything includedTiered add-ons

Same easy trading, plus automation and compliance that When I Work leaves to you.

Where When I Work wins

Price, for a lot of teams. Their Essentials tier was $2.50 per user per month when we checked on 2026-08-12, which undercuts most paid scheduling tiers including ours once you are past our free limit. If the requirement is a clean shared schedule and a time clock for a team that is already running smoothly, that is a genuinely good deal and this page is not going to argue with it.

They are also long established and widely used, which means most staff have either used it or something that looks like it. Familiarity has a real cost saving attached when you are rolling out to people who did not ask for new software.

Scheduling depth against breadth

The two products are aimed at different problems. A broad tool covers scheduling, messaging and time tracking at a level that suits a team whose scheduling is not the hard part. A narrow one goes further into the scheduling itself: compliance packs cited to statute, coverage requirements by daypart, fairness weighting in how work is distributed.

That depth is worth paying for only if scheduling is where your week actually goes. If the rota takes twenty minutes and nobody argues about it, breadth is the better buy and you should not let a comparison page talk you out of it.

What happens in the hour after a call-out

This is the scenario worth testing in both trials, because it is the one that recurs. Somebody drops out at short notice and the shift is in four hours.

Ask what the tool does unprompted. Does it notify everybody and hope, does it show a list of names, or does it rank the people who can genuinely take it against qualification, availability and the rules that would block them, and explain the ranking? Those are three very different products, and the difference only becomes visible under time pressure, which is exactly when a demo will not show it to you.

Also comparing

Other side-by-sides

vs Deputyvs Homebasevs Connecteam
Why it holds

The same engine underneath.

1 app
scheduling, time clock, and timesheets
Every pick
explained and reversible
< 4 min
to a running demo workspace
Questions

Formclock and When I Work, answered.

Pricing figures on this page were read off When I Work's own pricing page on 2026-08-12.

Which is cheaper?+
It depends on team size. When I Work's Essentials tier was $2.50 per user per month when we checked on 2026-08-12, which undercuts most paid scheduling tiers including ours. Formclock is free to 5 people and prices paid tiers by how much the coverage agent is trusted to act. Below the free-tier limit we cost nothing; above it, compare the tier contents rather than the headline rate.
What does When I Work do better?+
Price at the entry tier, and a longer track record. It has been in this category far longer than Formclock has, which shows in integration breadth and in the volume of people who already know the product.
Does either handle multiple locations properly?+
Both support multiple locations. The difference is what happens to a person who works across them: in Formclock each site keeps its own grid, positions and timezone, and hours worked across sites total together for overtime rather than being counted separately per location.
Is there a free plan?+
When I Work offered a 14-day trial rather than a free plan when we checked on 2026-08-12. Formclock stays free for up to 5 people with no time limit.

See it with your own schedule

Set up a workspace, add your team, and build a week. It takes about ten minutes and costs nothing.

Start free